Myth of the West: How the Western Influenced Other Genres

The influence of the Western genre extends far beyond the frontier. This article explores how Western themes, characters, and moral conflicts have shaped genres such as sci-fi, neo-noir, and anime, showing the versatility and enduring appeal of the Western myth.

Introduction

The myth of the West and its cultural narrative have not been confined to the traditional boundaries of the Western genre. Over time, the themes, tropes, and iconography of Westerns have infiltrated and influenced various other genres, from science fiction and post-apocalyptic tales to superhero films and anime. The core elements of the Western—rugged individualism, lawlessness, frontier justice, and the tension between civilisation and wilderness—have proven adaptable, resonating across diverse settings and time periods. This section explores how the Western has left its mark on other genres, showing the versatility and enduring power of its themes.

This article was inspired by conversations with my son, Bill, during his degree course at the University of Birmingham in English Literature. It is the sixth of my “Myth of the West” cycle.

Science Fiction as the New Frontier

The most obvious genre to incorporate Western themes is science fiction, particularly space Westerns, which transpose the frontier ethos from the American West to the cosmos. Just as the traditional Western depicted the untamed landscapes of the American frontier, space Westerns envision the vast, lawless expanse of the universe as a new frontier to be conquered.

One of the earliest and most prominent examples is Star Wars (1977), which blends the myth of the West with elements of mythology, samurai films, and adventure serials. Han Solo, portrayed by Harrison Ford, is essentially a space cowboy, a smuggler with a moral code and quick draw, navigating lawless regions of space much like the gunslingers of classic Westerns. The desert planet Tatooine echoes the arid landscapes of Monument Valley, and the Mos Eisley cantina serves as a saloon filled with rogues and bounty hunters straight out of a Western.

Similarly, the television show Firefly (2002), created by Joss Whedon, is often described as a direct space Western. Its main character, Captain Malcolm Reynolds (Nathan Fillion), is a former soldier turned smuggler and outlaw, much like the protagonists of revisionist Westerns. The show’s aesthetic combines futuristic technology with the rustic, dusty feel of the Old West, where lawmen and outlaws are constantly at odds in the frontier-like outer planets. Firefly emphasises the Western’s themes of individualism and survival in a hostile, lawless environment.

The genre-blurring Westworld (2016–), which merges Western motifs with science fiction and AI, explores the moral complexities of frontier life through a futuristic theme park where guests interact with artificially intelligent hosts in a simulated Old West setting. Westworld delves into philosophical questions about freedom, violence, and morality—central themes of the Western genre—while simultaneously engaging with the science fiction trope of artificial intelligence and human consciousness.

Post-Apocalyptic Westerns

The post-apocalyptic genre has also drawn heavily from Western tropes, as it often envisions a world where society has collapsed and lawlessness prevails—conditions that mirror the chaos and uncertainty of the American frontier. In post-apocalyptic worlds, the Western hero archetype, typically a lone wanderer or survivor, re-emerges in a future setting, dealing with the same moral dilemmas and survival challenges as the gunslingers of the Old West.

One of the most famous examples is the Mad Max series (1979–2015), directed by George Miller. Set in a post-apocalyptic wasteland, the series follows Max Rockatansky (Mel Gibson, later Tom Hardy), a lone anti-hero navigating a world of scavengers, bandits, and violent warlords. The open, desolate landscapes of the films echo the iconic settings of Westerns, and Max’s role as a wandering, reluctant saviour who brings rough justice to the lawless wasteland mirrors the Western cowboy. In Mad Max: Fury Road (2015), the dusty desert environment and the constant struggle for survival strongly evoke the Western ethos of the harsh, unforgiving frontier.

Another notable example is The Book of Eli (2010), a film that takes place in a post-apocalyptic America. The protagonist, Eli (Denzel Washington), is a lone drifter who wanders through a barren, lawless landscape, much like a cowboy. His mission to protect a sacred book aligns with the Western trope of a hero with a moral code, even as he resorts to violence in his quest. The film’s bleak vision of the future and its themes of survival, faith, and justice resonate with the core elements of the Western genre.

Superheroes and Western Archetypes

The superhero genre, particularly in recent years, has drawn inspiration from the Western’s moral complexity and character archetypes. Many superhero films feature lone vigilantes, often operating outside the law, who wrestle with their own moral codes while delivering justice in a chaotic world. This parallels the Western hero’s role as a reluctant lawman or gunslinger.

Logan (2017), directed by James Mangold, is perhaps the most explicit example of a superhero film using Western tropes. The film portrays an ageing Wolverine (Hugh Jackman) in a future where mutants are nearly extinct. Logan, like the classic Western hero, is a reluctant protector who has grown weary of violence but is drawn back into action to defend a vulnerable young girl. The film is heavily inspired by Clint Eastwood’s Unforgiven (1992) and other revisionist Westerns, in which the mythic hero confronts his violent past and struggles with questions of redemption.

The Western influence in Logan is further underscored by direct references to Western films within the narrative. In one scene, the characters watch Shane (1953), a classic Western about a gunfighter who tries to leave his violent past behind, only to be drawn into conflict once again. Like Shane, Logan is a tragic figure whose quest for peace is ultimately thwarted by the violence inherent in his world.

Similarly, Christopher Nolan’s The Dark Knight (2008) incorporates Western themes, with Batman (Christian Bale) cast as a vigilante sheriff in a modern-day Gotham City. The film explores themes of law, order, and vigilantism, much like classic Westerns, and features a moral conflict between the hero and the villain, the Joker (Heath Ledger), that echoes the black hat versus white hat dynamic of Westerns.

Anime and Western Influence

The Western genre has also made its way into Japanese anime, which has historically drawn from Western film and literature. One of the best-known examples is Cowboy Bebop (1998), a space Western that follows a group of bounty hunters as they travel through the galaxy in pursuit of criminals. The show combines the aesthetics of classic Westerns—dusty towns, saloons, shootouts—with the sci-fi elements of space travel and futuristic technology. Its protagonist, Spike Spiegel, is a cool, detached anti-hero with a tragic past, similar to the Western lone gunman archetype.

Another anime, Trigun (1998), is set in a desert wasteland and follows Vash the Stampede, a wandering gunman with a reputation for causing destruction, though he himself is a pacifist. The series blends traditional Western tropes—gunslingers, outlaws, and frontier towns—with science fiction, creating a hybrid genre that reflects the global influence of the Western.

Neo-Noir and Western Fusion

In recent decades, the Western’s influence has extended into neo-noir films, with works like No Country for Old Men (2007) blending the desolate landscapes and moral ambiguity of Westerns with the psychological tension and dark, fatalistic tone of noir. Directed by the Coen Brothers, No Country for Old Men uses the arid Texas borderlands as a modern Western backdrop, where lawlessness and violence reign. The film’s antagonist, Anton Chigurh (Javier Bardem), embodies a kind of nihilistic evil that reflects the moral ambiguity often found in revisionist Westerns.

The film blurs the line between genres, using Western landscapes and themes of frontier justice, but infusing them with the sensibility of noir, where fate is inescapable and violence is often senseless. Like the revisionist Westerns that came before it, No Country for Old Men critiques the black-and-white moral world of earlier Westerns, offering a more complex, morally grey vision of the modern frontier.

Conclusion

The influence of the Western genre extends far beyond its own cinematic and literary boundaries. Its themes, characters, and visual iconography have shaped numerous other genres, from science fiction and post-apocalyptic tales to superhero films and anime. The Western’s core conflicts—individualism versus society, civilisation versus wilderness, law versus lawlessness—continue to resonate in these varied settings, proving the genre’s enduring appeal and adaptability.

As the Western myth has evolved, its presence in other genres has become a testament to the versatility of its themes. Whether set in space, a dystopian future, or a modern city, the spirit of the Western remains alive in stories that grapple with moral ambiguity, survival, and the quest for justice in an often lawless world. The genre’s influence has transcended its own borders, leaving an indelible mark on global storytelling.